Magic Pizza
Ratings and Reviews

Want to know what customers really think about Magic Pizza?
This page shows real guest reviews, brand-wide ratings, and reputation stats across all U.S. locations.

Data Last Updated: 

July 1, 2025

See Magic Pizza's official site
⭐ Average Rating
3.6
🧮 Total Number of Reviews
3,297
⚠️ Reviews 1–3 Stars
36%
🚫 Stores Under 4 Stars
88%
🔁 Review Response Rate
4.90%
📝 Average Number of Reviews per Store
206

How Many Magic Pizza
Locations Are There in the U.S.?

Magic Pizza operates 16 locations across the United States, based on available review data.
See 16 Magic Pizza Locations on Atlas by Superorder

Recent Magic Pizza
Guest Reviews From Real Customers

Star Rating
Date
Comment
July 2025

It's pjs; sometimes it's worth the money- other times notsomuch...

July 2025

Always delicious, great & friendly staff 👍

June 2025

<p>Gave us a shitty ass pizza & not cooked garlic knots, straight dough 🤮</p>

June 2025

if you can’t keep up with to go orders don’t take them

June 2025

Staff is always upbeat and friendly no matter how busy!

This content is derived from publicly available customer feedback. Reviews are summarized for display and do not represent the views of Superorder.

How Multi-Location Restaurants Improve Reviews with Superorder

Superorder works with leading brands to improve customer satisfaction, resolve issues faster, and surface insights from every review. Our platform automates review management so teams can focus on what matters most.

Learn more

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Magic Pizza respond to customer reviews online?
Magic Pizza replies to 4.90% of customer reviews on Google, based on publicly available data across all U.S. locations. Some locations respond more actively than others, but this is the brand-wide average.
How many customer reviews does Magic Pizza have across all locations?
Magic Pizza has received 3,297 total reviews across its locations on Google.
Where do Magic Pizza's ratings come from?
Ratings shown on this page are based on Google reviews from customers at Magic Pizza locations nationwide. The overall rating is an average of all available review data.
Is Magic Pizza actively managing its online reputation?
Based on review response rate and activity, Magic Pizza appears to be actively monitoring guest feedback on Google. 4.90% of its reviews receive direct replies from the brand or location staff.
Based on public data, Magic Pizza does not consistently respond to customer reviews on Google. While some individual locations may reply occasionally, the overall brand response rate is currently low or inactive.

Explore More Chains

Check out reviews for other popular brands:

Le Pain Quotidien
Louisiana Fish House
Taquerias Arandas
Upward Projects
Old School Bagel Cafe

AI Agents for reputation management and delivery profitability

Products
Surveys & Feedback AgentReview Management AgentDelivery Profitability AgentsAI Scorecards, Insights & Alerts
Customers
Why Superorder?Case StudiesPricing
Resources
BlogPressRestaurant Reviews
© Superorder 2025
Virtual Restaurant AgreementPrivacy PolicySuperSuite Agreement